4. Thistleclaw

Thistleclaw has no good reason to be evil. Various other villains have a reason to be evil, such as Brokenstar getting neglected as a kit, Mapleshade getting blamed by Appledusk, etc. But Thistleclaw has no good reason. Sure, he was heartbroken after Snowfur's death, but that's not a reason to turn evil. All cats have lost their mates. Even the greatest warriors. Now... INFORMATION!!! Status: Deceased Cause of death: Killed by a RiverClan patrol Coming osoon